Free 30-minute consultation for new clients — book this week →
CTChinaTradeAttorney.com
Contracts· 3 min read

Force Majeure Under Chinese Contract Law: What the COVID-Era Cases Taught Us

Chinese law has a real, statutory force majeure doctrine — and the pandemic stress-tested it. What actually excuses non-performance, what the CCPIT certificate is worth, and how to draft for the next disruption.

When supply chains seized up in 2020, thousands of Chinese suppliers sent their foreign buyers a one-page "force majeure certificate" and went quiet. Some were genuinely excused; many were not. The litigation that followed gave us the clearest picture yet of how force majeure actually works under Chinese law — lessons worth applying before the next disruption, whatever its cause.

The statutory test is real, and narrow

Unlike common-law systems, where force majeure exists only if the contract says so, Chinese law builds it into statute. The Civil Code excuses a party from liability where performance is prevented by circumstances that are, cumulatively, unforeseeable, unavoidable and insurmountable. Three consequences follow:

  • The doctrine applies even to contracts with no force majeure clause, if Chinese law governs.
  • The exemption is proportionate: liability is excused only to the extent the event actually prevented performance. A two-week shutdown does not excuse a six-month delay.
  • It excuses non-performance; it does not by itself rewrite prices or shift costs.

What the COVID-era cases actually decided

Chinese courts handled enormous volumes of pandemic-related contract disputes, guided by several Supreme People's Court instruments. The pattern that emerged:

  1. Government-ordered closures and transport bans were treated as force majeure for obligations they directly blocked — a factory legally prohibited from operating could not be liable for the resulting delay.
  2. Market consequences were not. Falling demand, rising raw-material prices, expensive freight and labour shortages were generally analysed under the separate doctrine of change of circumstances (情势变更) — which leads to renegotiation or judicial adjustment of the contract, not free exemption. Parties who claimed force majeure because performance became unprofitable usually lost.
  3. Causation was scrutinised. Sellers already in delay before the event, or who could have performed by reasonable alternative means (another port, another workshop), were not excused.
  4. Procedure mattered enormously. The Civil Code requires the affected party to notify the counterparty promptly and provide evidence within a reasonable time, and both sides must mitigate. Suppliers who notified late — or used the event as cover to reallocate capacity to better-paying customers — were stripped of the defence.

The CCPIT certificate: useful, not magic

The China Council for the Promotion of International Trade issued tens of thousands of force majeure certificates during the pandemic. Understand what they are: factual attestations that an event (a lockdown order, a closure notice) occurred. Chinese courts give them evidentiary weight; they do not decide the legal question of whether that event prevented this party from performing this obligation. Foreign courts and arbitral tribunals applying non-Chinese law often give them less weight still. If you receive one, respond by asking the questions the certificate does not answer: which obligation, prevented how, for how long, and what alternatives were attempted.

Drafting for the next event

The statutory doctrine is a floor. A well-drafted China contract improves on it:

  • Define the event list and its edges — epidemics, government orders, export restrictions, cyber incidents — and state expressly what does not qualify (market price movements, currency fluctuation, the counterparty's subcontractor failing for its own reasons).
  • Hard notice mechanics: written notice within a fixed period (for example 7 days) with supporting evidence, failing which the defence is waived to the extent notice would have allowed mitigation.
  • A termination trigger: either party may terminate if the event continues beyond an agreed period — 60 or 90 days is common — with a clean rule for deposits and goods in progress.
  • Allocate the hardship cases by contract rather than leaving them to a court's discretion under change-of-circumstances: price-adjustment formulas, capacity-allocation commitments, alternative-sourcing rights.
  • Pair the clause with your remedies architecture — liquidated damages, payment holdbacks and a usable CIETAC arbitration clause — so the incentives to over-claim force majeure stay low.

The pandemic's core lesson was not that force majeure is generous or stingy. It is that the doctrine rewards the party with discipline: prompt notice, honest causation, documented mitigation. Build that discipline into the contract while relations are good.

Get a free consultation

By submitting you agree to our privacy policy. No spam, ever.

Related insights

Discuss your China matter with a lawyer

A free 30-minute consultation. Plain answers about your options, timelines and costs — and an honest view on whether you need a lawyer at all.

Call usGet Help Now